Today, 09:26 AM
When you boot up MLB The Show 25 Stubs, one of the most exciting parts is building your own dream team. Whether you’re crafting a roster in Franchise Mode, Diamond Dynasty, or Road to the Show, there’s a real joy in choosing the perfect mix of players, balancing power, speed, defense, and pitching.
But what if you didn’t pick a single player? What if you just let the game itself build your "best" team automatically?
That’s exactly what I decided to do. I handed over the reins to MLB The Show 25’s team-building algorithms and sat back to see what it would create. Would the game’s choice measure up to my baseball instincts? Would it craft a competitive squad ready to dominate the league? Or would it reveal surprising weaknesses?
Here’s a full breakdown of my experience, what the game chose, and what I learned from letting the game build my “best” team.
Why Let MLB The Show Build My Team?
Before jumping into the results, it’s worth understanding why I decided to let the game pick my team:
Curiosity: I wanted to see how the game’s AI prioritizes players based on stats, attributes, and ratings.
Challenge: Sometimes, creating a team yourself can lead to bias toward favorite players or personal favorites. Letting the game choose removes that.
Discovery: This method could introduce me to players I might overlook but who actually provide great value.
Experimentation: It’s an interesting way to test if the game’s evaluations truly align with on-field performance.
I used MLB The Show 25’s auto team-building feature in Diamond Dynasty mode, where the game selects players for each position based on overall ratings, chemistry, and budget constraints.
The Team Composition: Surprises and Selections
Once the auto-build was complete, I examined the lineup, rotation, bullpen, and bench.
Offense: The Lineup
The lineup was a mix of high-rated sluggers, solid contact hitters, and speedy base stealers. Interestingly, the game valued balance but leaned slightly toward power hitters.
Catchers and Infield: The catcher was a veteran with great defensive skills and respectable batting stats. The infield featured a mix of gold-rated players, with some surprise picks who had strong plate discipline stats rather than pure power.
Outfield: The outfield was stacked with a couple of dynamic power hitters and a speedy center fielder with excellent fielding metrics.
Designated Hitter (DH): The DH spot was occupied by a classic slugger, someone with high power and clutch hitting attributes.
Pitching Staff
The rotation consisted of pitchers with high velocity and solid control, but some with unusual pitch mixes. The game seemed to prioritize strikeout potential and stamina in starters, while the bullpen focused on pitchers with great velocity and good breaking balls for late-inning strikeouts.
How Did the Team Perform?
I jumped right into several games with this auto-built team to test its strengths and weaknesses.
Strengths
Balanced Offense: The lineup was versatile, able to adapt to various pitching styles. Power hitters could clear the fences, but the contact hitters kept the offense moving with singles and doubles.
Solid Defense: The defensive metrics were impressive, especially in the outfield. The center fielder made several highlight-reel catches.
Strong Starting Rotation: The starting pitchers could go deep into games without a big drop-off in performance. The high strikeout rates helped limit opposing offenses.
Weaknesses
Bench Depth: The bench was somewhat light on speed and defensive versatility, which made late-game substitutions less flexible.
Lack of Clutch Situations Specialists: While the team had power, it lacked players with strong "clutch" ratings who excel in high-pressure moments.
Bullpen Variability: Although some relievers had excellent velocity, others struggled with command, leading to occasional late-inning struggles.
What I Learned From Letting the Game Choose
1. The Game Values High Overall Ratings but Also Chemistry
MLB The Show 25’s auto team-builder doesn’t just stack the highest-rated players blindly. It factors in team chemistry, positional needs, and budget constraints, balancing raw skill with team cohesion.
This led to some unexpected player choices that initially seemed odd but made sense in the bigger picture. For example, the team picked a catcher with good leadership traits and battery chemistry with the starting pitchers — even though he wasn’t the highest-rated batter.
2. Star Power Still Reigns Supreme
Despite the balancing act, the game naturally favored players with high power and high ratings. If you want a “best” team to compete at the highest level, you’ll see the usual suspects — top sluggers, ace pitchers, and gold-level defenders.
3. Depth and Flexibility Are Sacrificed in Auto-Builds
The team lacked some of the nuanced depth that human team-builders tend to prioritize — like speed off the bench, pinch-running specialists, or defensive replacements.
In real baseball and the game’s higher-level modes, having a flexible bench is critical. This is an area where human intuition still beats the algorithm.
Would I Use the Auto-Build Feature Again?
If you’re short on time or just want a quick competitive squad, the auto-build feature in MLB The Show 25 is a fantastic starting point. It takes away the headache of player scouting, contract management, and chemistry balancing.
However, for players who enjoy the nuances of roster construction and tailoring a team to their playstyle, this feature serves more as a helpful baseline than a final solution.
Tips for Using MLB The Show’s Auto Team Builder
If you decide to try the auto team-building feature yourself, here are some tips:
Review the team carefully: Make sure to check the lineup and bullpen for glaring weaknesses.
Make manual tweaks: Don’t hesitate to swap out bench players or relievers to fit your style.
Use the auto-build as a foundation: Build from there, adjusting according to your preferred strategies.
Pay attention to chemistry: Chemistry affects performance in MLB The Show 25, so try to maintain good links between players.
Experiment with multiple auto-builds: Sometimes the algorithm will produce different teams based on budget and settings.
Final Thoughts
Letting MLB The Show 25 create my “best” team was a fascinating experiment. It revealed how the game evaluates player value, prioritizes team chemistry, and balances offense and defense.
While the AI-created team performed admirably, it reminded me of the importance of human judgment in roster construction — especially for depth, role players, and clutch performers.
Whether you’re a casual player or a franchise mode strategist, the auto-build feature is a powerful tool in MLB The Show 25, but it’s best used alongside your own baseball knowledge and intuition.
So, the next time you want to [/url][url=https://www.mmoexp.com/Mlb-the-show-25/Stubs.html]MLB The Show for sale shake things up or just jump straight into action, try letting the game build your team. You might be surprised by who it picks — and how well they perform.
But what if you didn’t pick a single player? What if you just let the game itself build your "best" team automatically?
That’s exactly what I decided to do. I handed over the reins to MLB The Show 25’s team-building algorithms and sat back to see what it would create. Would the game’s choice measure up to my baseball instincts? Would it craft a competitive squad ready to dominate the league? Or would it reveal surprising weaknesses?
Here’s a full breakdown of my experience, what the game chose, and what I learned from letting the game build my “best” team.
Why Let MLB The Show Build My Team?
Before jumping into the results, it’s worth understanding why I decided to let the game pick my team:
Curiosity: I wanted to see how the game’s AI prioritizes players based on stats, attributes, and ratings.
Challenge: Sometimes, creating a team yourself can lead to bias toward favorite players or personal favorites. Letting the game choose removes that.
Discovery: This method could introduce me to players I might overlook but who actually provide great value.
Experimentation: It’s an interesting way to test if the game’s evaluations truly align with on-field performance.
I used MLB The Show 25’s auto team-building feature in Diamond Dynasty mode, where the game selects players for each position based on overall ratings, chemistry, and budget constraints.
The Team Composition: Surprises and Selections
Once the auto-build was complete, I examined the lineup, rotation, bullpen, and bench.
Offense: The Lineup
The lineup was a mix of high-rated sluggers, solid contact hitters, and speedy base stealers. Interestingly, the game valued balance but leaned slightly toward power hitters.
Catchers and Infield: The catcher was a veteran with great defensive skills and respectable batting stats. The infield featured a mix of gold-rated players, with some surprise picks who had strong plate discipline stats rather than pure power.
Outfield: The outfield was stacked with a couple of dynamic power hitters and a speedy center fielder with excellent fielding metrics.
Designated Hitter (DH): The DH spot was occupied by a classic slugger, someone with high power and clutch hitting attributes.
Pitching Staff
The rotation consisted of pitchers with high velocity and solid control, but some with unusual pitch mixes. The game seemed to prioritize strikeout potential and stamina in starters, while the bullpen focused on pitchers with great velocity and good breaking balls for late-inning strikeouts.
How Did the Team Perform?
I jumped right into several games with this auto-built team to test its strengths and weaknesses.
Strengths
Balanced Offense: The lineup was versatile, able to adapt to various pitching styles. Power hitters could clear the fences, but the contact hitters kept the offense moving with singles and doubles.
Solid Defense: The defensive metrics were impressive, especially in the outfield. The center fielder made several highlight-reel catches.
Strong Starting Rotation: The starting pitchers could go deep into games without a big drop-off in performance. The high strikeout rates helped limit opposing offenses.
Weaknesses
Bench Depth: The bench was somewhat light on speed and defensive versatility, which made late-game substitutions less flexible.
Lack of Clutch Situations Specialists: While the team had power, it lacked players with strong "clutch" ratings who excel in high-pressure moments.
Bullpen Variability: Although some relievers had excellent velocity, others struggled with command, leading to occasional late-inning struggles.
What I Learned From Letting the Game Choose
1. The Game Values High Overall Ratings but Also Chemistry
MLB The Show 25’s auto team-builder doesn’t just stack the highest-rated players blindly. It factors in team chemistry, positional needs, and budget constraints, balancing raw skill with team cohesion.
This led to some unexpected player choices that initially seemed odd but made sense in the bigger picture. For example, the team picked a catcher with good leadership traits and battery chemistry with the starting pitchers — even though he wasn’t the highest-rated batter.
2. Star Power Still Reigns Supreme
Despite the balancing act, the game naturally favored players with high power and high ratings. If you want a “best” team to compete at the highest level, you’ll see the usual suspects — top sluggers, ace pitchers, and gold-level defenders.
3. Depth and Flexibility Are Sacrificed in Auto-Builds
The team lacked some of the nuanced depth that human team-builders tend to prioritize — like speed off the bench, pinch-running specialists, or defensive replacements.
In real baseball and the game’s higher-level modes, having a flexible bench is critical. This is an area where human intuition still beats the algorithm.
Would I Use the Auto-Build Feature Again?
If you’re short on time or just want a quick competitive squad, the auto-build feature in MLB The Show 25 is a fantastic starting point. It takes away the headache of player scouting, contract management, and chemistry balancing.
However, for players who enjoy the nuances of roster construction and tailoring a team to their playstyle, this feature serves more as a helpful baseline than a final solution.
Tips for Using MLB The Show’s Auto Team Builder
If you decide to try the auto team-building feature yourself, here are some tips:
Review the team carefully: Make sure to check the lineup and bullpen for glaring weaknesses.
Make manual tweaks: Don’t hesitate to swap out bench players or relievers to fit your style.
Use the auto-build as a foundation: Build from there, adjusting according to your preferred strategies.
Pay attention to chemistry: Chemistry affects performance in MLB The Show 25, so try to maintain good links between players.
Experiment with multiple auto-builds: Sometimes the algorithm will produce different teams based on budget and settings.
Final Thoughts
Letting MLB The Show 25 create my “best” team was a fascinating experiment. It revealed how the game evaluates player value, prioritizes team chemistry, and balances offense and defense.
While the AI-created team performed admirably, it reminded me of the importance of human judgment in roster construction — especially for depth, role players, and clutch performers.
Whether you’re a casual player or a franchise mode strategist, the auto-build feature is a powerful tool in MLB The Show 25, but it’s best used alongside your own baseball knowledge and intuition.
So, the next time you want to [/url][url=https://www.mmoexp.com/Mlb-the-show-25/Stubs.html]MLB The Show for sale shake things up or just jump straight into action, try letting the game build your team. You might be surprised by who it picks — and how well they perform.